Skip to main content

HostGator Email Going to Spam? Correctly Set Up SPF and DKIM Records

 Nothing erodes business credibility faster than a "Check your spam folder" disclaimer during a client call. If you are hosting on HostGator and your transactional emails, invoices, or newsletters are consistently flagged as junk, the issue is rarely the content of your email.

The problem lies in the technical handshake between HostGator’s outgoing mail servers and the recipient's inbox (Gmail, Outlook, Yahoo). Default shared hosting configurations often fail to align the "Envelope Sender" with your domain identity.

This guide provides a rigorous, root-cause analysis of why this failure occurs on HostGator's infrastructure and details the exact DNS configuration required to authenticate your emails via SPF (Sender Policy Framework) and DKIM (DomainKeys Identified Mail).

The Root Cause: Shared IP Reputation and Relay Architecture

To fix email deliverability, you must understand the path your email travels. When you click "Send" via a HostGator hosted account (whether via PHP mail(), SMTP, or Webmail), your email does not go directly from your specific server slice to the recipient.

  1. The Relay Gateway: HostGator routes outgoing mail through a massive cluster of shared mail gateways (often routed under websitewelcome.com).
  2. The Authorization Gap: By default, your domain's DNS might authorize your specific cPanel IP address to send mail. However, the actual email leaves HostGator’s network via a gateway IP, not your cPanel IP.
  3. The Result: Gmail sees an email claiming to be from yourbusiness.com, but it originates from an IP belonging to a generic HostGator relay. Without explicit authorization in your DNS records, Gmail treats this as a spoofing attempt.

Furthermore, because these IPs are shared, your reputation is tied to thousands of other customers. If a neighbor on your shared block sends spam, your delivery rates drop. Cryptographic authentication (DKIM) is the only way to distinguish your legitimate traffic from their noise.

Phase 1: Configuring SPF (Sender Policy Framework)

SPF is a DNS TXT record that lists every IP address or hostname authorized to send email on behalf of your domain.

The Common Mistake

Many automated cPanel setups generate a record like this: v=spf1 a mx ?all

This is insufficient. It tells receiving servers: "My web server IP (A record) and my incoming mail server (MX record) are allowed to send." It fails to account for HostGator's external relay gateways.

The Correct HostGator SPF Record

You must explicitly include HostGator's relay network. The primary include for HostGator shared hosting is websitewelcome.com.

The Record Syntax:

Type: TXT
Host/Name: @ (or your domain name)
Value: v=spf1 +a +mx +include:websitewelcome.com ~all

Breakdown of Flags

  • v=spf1: Identifies the record as SPF version 1.
  • +a: Authorizes the IP address defined in your domain's A record.
  • +mx: Authorizes the IPs defined in your domain's MX records.
  • +include:websitewelcome.com: Crucial. This recursively looks up the SPF record for websitewelcome.com and authorizes all HostGator gateways listed there.
  • ~all: Soft fail. This tells receivers, "If the email comes from somewhere else, accept it but mark it suspiciously." Once you confirm delivery works, you can switch to -all (hard fail) for stricter security, but ~all is safer for initial setup.

Phase 2: Implementing DKIM (DomainKeys Identified Mail)

While SPF validates the sender IP, DKIM ensures message integrity. It attaches a cryptographic signature to the email header. The receiving server uses a public key published in your DNS to verify that the email was not altered in transit.

HostGator's cPanel creates the private key locally, but you must ensure the public key is exposed via DNS.

Step 1: Generate the Keys in cPanel

  1. Log in to cPanel.
  2. Navigate to Email -> Email Deliverability.
  3. Locate your domain and click Manage.
  4. If DKIM is not already generated, click Install or Enable.

Step 2: The Selector and Key

cPanel will display a "DKIM Name" (Selector) and a "DKIM Value" (The Public Key).

  • Selector: Usually default or a specific string like default._domainkey.
  • Value: A long string starting with v=DKIM1; k=rsa; p=....

Step 3: Adding the DNS Record

If your nameservers point to HostGator, cPanel adds this automatically. However, if you use Cloudflare, GoDaddy, or AWS Route53 for DNS, you must manually copy this record to that provider.

The Record Syntax:

Type: TXT
Host/Name: default._domainkey
Value: v=DKIM1; k=rsa; p=MIIBIjANBgkqhkiG9w0BAQEFAAOCAQ8AMIIBCgKCAQEA...[rest of key]

Warning: DNS providers handle the "Host" field differently.

  • HostGator/GoDaddy: Enter default._domainkey
  • Cloudflare/AWS: Enter default._domainkey (some interfaces automatically append the domain, others require the full default._domainkey.yourdomain.com. Check your provider's documentation).

Phase 3: The "Split DNS" Pitfall

This is the most frequent point of failure for System Administrators managing HostGator accounts.

Scenario: You host your website files and email on HostGator, but you manage your domain's DNS records at Cloudflare (for CDN/Security) or a registrar like Namecheap.

If you change SPF/DKIM settings in cPanel, those changes are written to the local DNS zone on the HostGator server. However, the rest of the internet is querying Cloudflare/Namecheap.

The Fix: You must copy the v=spf1... value and the DKIM key generated in cPanel and manually create those TXT records in your external DNS provider's dashboard.

Verification and Testing

Do not assume configuration equals success. DNS propagation can take 1 to 24 hours (though typically minutes with Cloudflare).

1. Verify DNS Propagation

Use the command line to check if the world sees your new records.

# Verify SPF
dig +short TXT yourdomain.com

# Verify DKIM (Replace 'default' with your specific selector)
dig +short TXT default._domainkey.yourdomain.com

2. Verify Delivery Alignment

Send a test email from your HostGator account to a generic Gmail account. Open the email in Gmail, click the three dots in the top right, and select "Show Original".

Look for the authentication headers:

  • SPF: PASS with IP ...
  • DKIM: PASS with domain ...

If both say PASS, your authentication infrastructure is correctly configured.

Next Steps: DMARC

Once SPF and DKIM are passing consistently, you should implement DMARC (Domain-based Message Authentication, Reporting, and Conformance). DMARC tells receiving servers what to do if an email fails SPF or DKIM (e.g., Reject it or Quarantine it).

A safe starting DMARC record to collect data without blocking mail is:

Type: TXT
Host: _dmarc
Value: v=DMARC1; p=none; rua=mailto:admin@yourdomain.com

This ensures that while you monitor your delivery reports, no legitimate email is blocked, paving the way for a fully secure p=reject policy in the future.

Labels: