Skip to main content

Fixing the "403 Forbidden (Code 453)" Error in X API v2

 There are few experiences in software development more frustrating than generating valid API keys, copying boilerplate code, and being immediately rejected by the server.

If you are building a bot on the X (formerly Twitter) API Free Tier, you have likely encountered this JSON response when attempting to post a tweet:

{
  "title": "Forbidden",
  "detail": "You currently have access to a subset of Twitter API v2 endpoints...",
  "type": "about:blank",
  "status": 403,
  "errors": [
    {
      "message": "You currently have access to a subset of Twitter API v2 endpoints...",
      "code": 453
    }
  ]
}

This error is misleading. It suggests you are trying to access a restricted endpoint, but it often appears even when you are hitting valid endpoints like manage_tweets (POST /2/tweets).

The issue is rarely your code logic. It is almost always a desynchronization between your Developer Portal settings and the specific Access Token you are using. This guide provides the root cause analysis and the exact steps to resolve this for Python and Node.js environments.

The Root Cause: Why Code 453 Happens

To fix this, you must understand how X handles authentication scopes under the new API tiers.

1. The "Free Tier" Constraint

The Free tier is extremely restrictive. It allows you to:

  • Write: Create Tweets (POST /2/tweets) and Delete Tweets (DELETE /2/tweets/:id).
  • Read: Only the authenticated user's details (GET /2/users/me).
  • Limit: 1,500 posts per month.

If your code attempts to read a timeline, search for tweets, or look up another user, you will receive a 403 Forbidden. However, many developers get this error even when strictly trying to post.

2. The Token Permissions Mismatch

This is the technical reason for the failure. When you create an App in the Developer Portal, the default permission setting is often set to "Read".

If you generate your Access Token and Secret while the App is in "Read" mode, those tokens are permanently stamped with "Read-only" scope.

Even if you later toggle the switch in the dashboard to "Read and Write," your existing Access Tokens do not update automatically. They remain valid cryptographic keys, but they carry the old, insufficient permissions. Using a Read-only token to hit a Write-only endpoint triggers the Code 453 or 403 Forbidden error.

The Fix: Configuration and Token Regeneration

Before touching your code, you must correct the credentials source.

Step 1: Adjust User Authentication Settings

  1. Log in to the X Developer Portal.
  2. Navigate to Projects & Apps > [Your App Name].
  3. Click on the Settings icon next to "User authentication settings" (click "Set up" if you haven't yet).
  4. App permissions: Select "Read and Write".
  5. Type of App: Select "Web App, Automated App or Bot".
  6. Callback URI / Website URL: If you are building a server-side bot, you can use http://localhost:3000 and https://twitter.com as placeholders.
  7. Click Save.

Step 2: The Critical Step (Regenerate Tokens)

This is where most implementations fail. You must generate new keys that inherit the "Read and Write" permissions you just saved.

  1. Navigate to the Keys and Tokens tab of your App.
  2. Look for the Authentication Tokens section.
  3. Find Access Token and Secret.
  4. Click Regenerate.
  5. Store these new strings. These are the only credentials that will work for the code below.

Python Solution (Tweepy)

We will use tweepy, the industry-standard wrapper for the X API. Ensure you are using tweepy>=4.10.0 to support API v2.

Prerequisites

pip install tweepy

The Implementation

Do not use API() class (v1.1); use Client() (v2).

import tweepy
import os

# Configuration: Replace these with your REGENERATED keys
# In production, load these from environment variables (e.g., os.environ.get("..."))
CONSUMER_KEY = "YOUR_API_KEY"
CONSUMER_SECRET = "YOUR_API_KEY_SECRET"
ACCESS_TOKEN = "YOUR_ACCESS_TOKEN"
ACCESS_TOKEN_SECRET = "YOUR_ACCESS_TOKEN_SECRET"

def post_tweet():
    try:
        # Initialize the V2 Client
        # We pass wait_on_rate_limit=True to handle standard API throttling automatically
        client = tweepy.Client(
            consumer_key=CONSUMER_KEY,
            consumer_secret=CONSUMER_SECRET,
            access_token=ACCESS_TOKEN,
            access_token_secret=ACCESS_TOKEN_SECRET,
            wait_on_rate_limit=True
        )

        # Attempt to post the tweet
        # Note: text is the parameter for the tweet body
        response = client.create_tweet(text="Hello World! This is a test from the X API v2.")

        print(f"✅ Tweet successfully posted!")
        print(f"Tweet ID: {response.data['id']}")

    except tweepy.errors.Forbidden as e:
        print(f"❌ 403 Forbidden Error: {e}")
        print("Root Cause: Likely permissions mismatch. Did you regenerate Access Tokens AFTER setting 'Read and Write'?")
    except Exception as e:
        print(f"❌ An error occurred: {e}")

if __name__ == "__main__":
    post_tweet()

Node.js Solution (twitter-api-v2)

For Node.js, twitter-api-v2 is the most reliable, modern library with full TypeScript support.

Prerequisites

npm install twitter-api-v2

The Implementation

We will use the default TwitterApi client which handles the OAuth 1.0a signing headers required for the Free tier.

import { TwitterApi } from 'twitter-api-v2';

// Configuration
// Best Practice: Use process.env in production
const credentials = {
  appKey: 'YOUR_API_KEY',
  appSecret: 'YOUR_API_KEY_SECRET',
  accessToken: 'YOUR_ACCESS_TOKEN',
  accessSecret: 'YOUR_ACCESS_TOKEN_SECRET',
};

async function postTweet() {
  try {
    // Instantiate the client with OAuth 1.0a User Context
    const client = new TwitterApi(credentials);

    // X API v2 requires the read-write access level for this call
    const response = await client.v2.tweet('Hello World from Node.js and X API v2!');

    console.log('✅ Tweet successfully posted!');
    console.log(`Tweet ID: ${response.data.id}`);

  } catch (error) {
    if (error.code === 403) {
      console.error('❌ 403 Forbidden: Permissions Error.');
      console.error('Action: Verify App permissions are "Read and Write" and REGENERATE Access Tokens.');
    } else {
      console.error('❌ Error posting tweet:', error);
    }
  }
}

postTweet();

Deep Dive: Why "User Context" Matters

You might wonder why we need four keys (Consumer Key/Secret + Access Token/Secret) instead of just the Bearer Token.

The Bearer Token uses "App-only" authentication. It represents the application itself, not a specific user. App-only auth is generally read-only and is used for searching tweets or reading public metrics.

However, to create a tweet, the API needs to know who is tweeting. This requires User Context authentication (OAuth 1.0a). The Access Token and Secret represent the specific user (in this case, your own developer account) authorizing the application to write on their behalf.

On the Free tier, you cannot use the OAuth 2.0 Authorization Code Flow effectively for external users; you are limited to the credentials generated in your dashboard for your own account.

Common Pitfalls and Edge Cases

1. Checking Credentials (The "Verify" Trap)

Many developers add a "check credentials" step before tweeting:

# DO NOT DO THIS ON FREE TIER
client.get_me()

Or in v1.1: api.verify_credentials().

On the Free Tier, you often do not have read access to user endpoints depending on specific flag configurations. If your script crashes on a get_me() call, comment it out. Trust the create_tweet call to handle the validation.

2. System Time Synchronization

OAuth 1.0a relies heavily on timestamps to prevent replay attacks. If your server or local machine's clock is out of sync by even 30 seconds, X will reject the request with a 401 or 403 error. Ensure your server runs an NTP (Network Time Protocol) daemon.

3. Media Uploads

The code examples above handle text-only tweets. The Free tier has ambiguous support for media uploads.

  • Media upload is technically a v1.1 endpoint (upload.twitter.com).
  • While tweepy and twitter-api-v2 handle this, API access for media endpoints on the Free tier is frequently reported as unstable or restricted to the "Basic" tier ($100/mo). If you get a 403 specifically during media upload, you likely need to upgrade to Basic.

Conclusion

The "Code 453" error is rarely a code syntax error; it is a permission scope error. The X API does not dynamically check your current App settings against your old tokens.

By ensuring your app is set to "Read and Write" first, and then regenerating your Access Tokens, you align your cryptographic keys with the platform's requirements. Use the Code 453 as a signal to refresh your credentials, not rewrite your logic.

Labels: