Skip to main content

Why `RPi.GPIO` Fails on Raspberry Pi 5 (And How to Fix It)

 If you recently unboxed a Raspberry Pi 5, flashed Raspberry Pi OS Bookworm, and attempted to run your trusty Python scripts, you likely hit a wall. Scripts that have run reliably on the Pi 3 and 4 for years are suddenly throwing RuntimeError: No access to /dev/mem, ModuleNotFoundError, or worse—running silently without actually toggling any pins.

The industry-standard library RPi.GPIO is dead on the Raspberry Pi 5. Here is the architectural reason why, and the code-complete paths to get you back up and running.

The Root Cause: The RP1 Southbridge

To understand why your code broke, you have to look at the silicon.

On Raspberry Pi models 1 through 4, the GPIO pins were controlled directly by the main Broadcom System-on-Chip (SoC). Libraries like RPi.GPIO worked by memory-mapping (mmap) specific physical addresses on the SoC to toggle bits directly. This was fast, but it was a "dirty" hack that bypassed the Linux kernel's subsystems.

The Raspberry Pi 5 architecture is different. The main BCM2712 SoC does not control the GPIO header directly. Instead, it offloads I/O responsibilities to a separate, custom-designed I/O controller called the RP1, connected via a PCIe bus (Southbridge architecture).

Because the GPIOs are now behind the RP1 chip over a PCIe link, the physical memory addresses hardcoded into RPi.GPIO are invalid. The library is trying to write to memory addresses that no longer correspond to physical pins.

The Solution

There are two ways to fix this.

  1. The Drop-in Replacement: Best for legacy codebases where you cannot rewrite the logic.
  2. The Modern Standard: Best for new projects and long-term maintainability.

Solution A: The Drop-in Replacement (rpi-lgpio)

The community and Raspberry Pi engineers have released a compatibility shim. This library mimics the RPi.GPIO function signatures exactly but routes the calls through the modern Linux kernel GPIO character device (libgpio) instead of trying to hack memory addresses.

Step 1: Clean your environment First, ensure you remove the legacy library to avoid conflicts. (Note: If you are using a virtual environment, ensure it is activated).

# Remove the old, non-functional library
sudo apt remove python3-rpi.gpio

Step 2: Install the Compatibility Layer Install python3-rpi-lgpio. This package provides a module named RPi.GPIO, so your Python imports do not need to change.

sudo apt update
sudo apt install python3-rpi-lgpio

Step 3: Verification You do not need to change your Python code. Run your existing script. Below is a test script to verify the fix works.

import RPi.GPIO as GPIO
import time

# Use Broadcom pin numbering
GPIO.setmode(GPIO.BCM)
GPIO.setwarnings(False)

# Define the pin (e.g., GPIO 17)
LED_PIN = 17

try:
    GPIO.setup(LED_PIN, GPIO.OUT)
    print(f"Blinking LED on GPIO {LED_PIN} using rpi-lgpio...")
    
    for i in range(5):
        GPIO.output(LED_PIN, GPIO.HIGH)
        time.sleep(0.5)
        GPIO.output(LED_PIN, GPIO.LOW)
        time.sleep(0.5)
        
    print("Test Complete.")

except Exception as e:
    print(f"Error: {e}")

finally:
    GPIO.cleanup()

Solution B: The Modern Standard (gpiozero)

If you are writing new code or have the budget to refactor, stop using RPi.GPIO. The gpiozero library is the official standard. It abstracts the underlying hardware method, meaning the same code works on a Pi 4 (direct memory) and a Pi 5 (via lgpio backend) without changes.

Step 1: Install GPIO Zero It is likely installed by default, but ensure you have it:

sudo apt install python3-gpiozero

Step 2: The Implementation Notice how much cleaner the logic is. We rely on object-oriented state management rather than procedural pin toggling.

from gpiozero import LED
from time import sleep
from signal import pause

# gpiozero handles BCM numbering and cleanup automatically
# Pin 17 is the BCM number
led = LED(17)

print("Blinking LED on GPIO 17 using gpiozero...")

try:
    # blink(on_time, off_time, n=None, background=True)
    # n=None means blink forever
    led.blink(on_time=0.5, off_time=0.5)
    
    # Keep the script running to allow the background thread to work
    pause()

except KeyboardInterrupt:
    print("\nExiting safely...")
    # gpiozero handles GPIO cleanup on exit automatically

Why This Fix Works

The Linux GPIO Character Device

Linux moved away from direct memory access and the sysfs interface (/sys/class/gpio) years ago. The modern standard is the GPIO Character Device (typically /dev/gpiochipN).

  • Solution A (rpi-lgpio) acts as a translator. When you call GPIO.output(17, 1), the library translates that into a libgpio kernel system call requesting the kernel driver to toggle the pin on the RP1 chip.
  • Solution B (gpiozero) is built on top of pin factories. On a Pi 5, it automatically detects the hardware and selects the lgpio or native factory, handling the low-level communication with the RP1 chip transparently.

Conclusion

The breakage of RPi.GPIO on Raspberry Pi 5 is not a bug; it is a symptom of architectural progress. The move to the RP1 I/O controller allows for higher bandwidth and better peripheral performance, but it breaks the reliance on direct memory access.

For immediate relief, swap your package to python3-rpi-lgpio. For long-term viability, migrate your codebase to gpiozero.

Labels: